Tweet
Messy's always been a tough one to judge. He's hinted at a darker past, and even his present is dubious as to whether he can really be trusted to not take your head when you're not expecting it. Wells just seems like an average dude who fights only when provoked. If forced to fight, Messenger wins, because Ron Perlman. IE What he said.
-
-
The Messenger is not a pacifist anymore!
The Messenger Attack 4 Defence 3 Speed 77 Agility 55 Strength 88 Power: 220 Average: 44 Arrogance -10% -22 Adaptability 0% 0 Special skill: Total: 198
Next fight:
Annie Devlin versus Michael Kent
Annie Devlin Michael Kent Attack 26 Attack 82 Defence 24 Defence 85 Speed 24 Speed 72 Agility 24 Agility 73 Strength 27 Strength 73 Power: 125 VS. Power: 385 Average: 25 Average: 77 Arrogance 0% 0 Arrogance -1% -4 Adaptability 0% 0 Adaptability 0% 0 Special skill: Special skill: Neutral Total: 125 Neutral Total: 381 May flights of Demons guide you to your final rest...Comment
-
Kent, easily.Comment
-
You have said you just assign numbers. I think, as written, Annie would have been better than this. Though her arrogance and adaptability would have lowered her score.
So I'm going with Annie.Comment
-
True, I made up all stats. Still there is a system to it:
It largely follows the Tier list and the scale is from 0 to 500 with
0 = absolutely useless,
100 = decent,
200 = good,
300 = very good,
400 = exceptional,
500 = perfect.
With that in mind I set Amanda at 350 and The Kurgan at 440 and judged all immortals' visual performances as well as the watcher files. That way I got numbers relative to the other immortals of the Tier list starting from the top down. All immortals are at their best, which is why Richie is ranked higher than Mako even though Mako was better at the time they met, for example.
Some immortals have special skills to help them and I tried to incorporate them as faithfully as I could. But everything is up for debate and I do tinker with the numbers and special skills from time to time.
All these fights, votes and comments help me standardise the net gain from a victory over a better or weaker immortal opponent.
-
-
Michael Kent would beat her in less than 15 seconds.Comment
-
Michael Kent takes out the ferocious Annie Devlin!Next fight:Michael Kent Attack 90 Defence 94 Speed 79 Agility 80 Strength 80 Power: 424 Average: 85 Arrogance -1% -4 Adaptability 0% 0 Special skill: Total: 419
David Quinlan (Highlander: The Watcher) versus Bartholomew (Highlander: The Series)
David Quinlan Bartholomew Attack 50 Attack 78 Defence 50 Defence 87 Speed 50 Speed 78 Agility 50 Agility 75 Strength 50 Strength 85 Power: 250 VS. Power: 403 Average: 50 Average: 81 Arrogance -0% 0 Arrogance -2% -8 Adaptability 10% 25 Adaptability 0% 0 Special skill: Special skill: Inside information:
Negate opponents Defence & AdaptabilityShield bearer:
Bartolomew's Defence cannot be lowered.Total: 275 Evil Total: 395 May flights of Demons guide you to your final rest...Comment
-
I prefer David. I think he has knowledge that will help. Of course, you gave him a lot for adaptability.Comment
-
Thing with Bartholomew, is that shield gives him SUCH an obnoxious advantage in an open space against a single weapon fighter. You're going to have to have someone who is significantly better than Bartholomew to be able to take him down. Bartholomew is old and while he's a bit of a coward he has proven he's a patient fighter. His fight with Katharine went a long time - lots of credit to her for being patient too. Someone fighting someone with a shield may be overly aggressive to try to make something happen and she didn't do that. Kudos. Bartholomew was also not overly sloppy; he just got taken down by a better/smarter fighter.
This guy isn't going to do it. He probably puts up a brave fight but Bartholomew takes him down without much doubt in my mind. VOTE: BartComment
-
Aragorn makes some great points. I'm voting for Bartie.Comment
-
So Bartholomew takes down David Quinlan after a long fight!
Bartholomew Attack 86 Defence 96 Speed 86 Agility 83 Strength 94 Power: 443 Average: 89 Arrogance -2% -9 Adaptability 10% 44 Special skill: Shield bearer:
Bartolomew's Defence cannot be lowered.Total: 479
Next execution:
Antonius Kalas versus Derek Worth
Antonius Kalas Derek Worth Attack 86 Attack 6 Defence 82 Defence 6 Speed 82 Speed 7 Agility 80 Agility 9 Strength 87 Strength 10 Power: 417 VS. Power: 38 Average: 83 Average: 8 Arrogance -2% -8 Arrogance 0% 0 Adaptability 0% 0 Adaptability 0% 0 Special skill: Special skill: Psychological Warfare:
Lower opponents power by 15.Evil Total: 409 Good Total: 38 May flights of Demons guide you to your final rest...Comment
-
At least David got a long fight! Derek, oh poor Derek. No chance.Comment
-
Oof. Kalas toys with Derek a while. I could see Derek getting in a surprise move or two, but nothing that would make much of a difference in the end. Kalas takes it.Comment
-
Yeah this fight lasts as long as Kalas wants it to. He also gets t pick the winner, so ... Kalas wins.Comment
-
Kalas takes whatever Derek was worth!
Next fight:Antonius Kalas Attack 95 Defence 90 Speed 90 Agility 88 Strength 96 Power: 459 Average: 92 Arrogance -2% -9 Adaptability 0% 0 Special skill: Psychological Warfare:
Lower opponents power by 15.Total: 450
Morgan Walker versus Hamza El Kahir
Morgan Walker Hamza el Kahir Attack 40 Attack 58 Defence 46 Defence 58 Speed 50 Speed 58 Agility 50 Agility 58 Strength 45 Strength 58 Power: 231 VS. Power: 290 Average: 46 Average: 58 Arrogance -2% -5 Arrogance 0% 0 Adaptability 0% 0 Adaptability 0% 0 Special skill: Special skill: Neutral Total: 226 Good Total: 290 May flights of Demons guide you to your final rest...Comment
-
Don't really think ol' Morg has the skills, going with Hamza for this bout.Comment
-
I see these two on a fairly even level, maybe a slight advantage to Hamza (at least Xavier knew of the guy by reputation). So el Kahir takes it.Comment
-
I think this would be a good fight. I think Hamza had more experience and abilities but Morgan has more modern training which would help him. I agree with the others that Hamza would most likely take it.Comment
-
I am biased in favor of Hamza, anyway. Plus Morgan doesn't just have a lower score, he's a weasel.Comment
-
Hamza takes out the weasly Walker!
Hamza el Kahir Attack 64 Defence 64 Speed 64 Agility 64 Strength 64 Power: 319 Average: 64 Arrogance -2% -6 Adaptability 0% 0 Special skill: Total: 313
Next fight:
Kate Devany (Highlander: Endgame) versus Ximena (Highlander: Dark Places)
Kate Devaney Ximena Attack 8 Attack 53 Defence 8 Defence 52 Speed 8 Speed 60 Agility 8 Agility 72 Strength 8 Strength 55 Power: 40 VS. Power: 292 Average: 8 Average: 58 Arrogance -3% -1 Arrogance 0% 0 Adaptability 0% 0 Adaptability 0% 0 Special skill: Special skill: Seduction:
If opponent is Good or Evil lower his/her Strength by 15.Dual Wield: Lower opponents defence by 10. Neutral Total: 39 Total: 292 May flights of Demons guide you to your final rest...Comment
-
Ximena wins in a landslide. She's cool!Comment
-
Kate's just not a fighter. Should would take someone like Sharon but not anyone with any real combat experience. So Xiemena as she clearly has some experience.Comment
-
I'm not waiting for the 3rd vote on this one:
Ximena absorbs what little Faith had to offer.
Ximena Attack 58 Defence 57 Speed 66 Agility 79 Strength 61 Power: 321 Average: 64 Arrogance -3% -10 Adaptability 0% 0 Special skill: Dual Wield: Lower opponents defence by 10. Total: 312
Next fight:
Caleb Cole (Highlander: The Series) versus Frank Brennan (HIghlander: The Raven)
Caleb Cole Frank Brennan Attack 80 Attack 70 Defence 70 Defence 60 Speed 70 Speed 40 Agility 70 Agility 60 Strength 84 Strength 65 Power: 374 VS. Power: 295 Average: 75 Average: 59 Arrogance -1% -4 Arrogance 0 -3 Adaptability 0% 0 Adaptability 0 0 Special skill: Special skill: Ranged shot:
Lower opponents Agility by 35.Neutral Total: 370 Total: 292
May flights of Demons guide you to your final rest...Comment
-
Tricky! On the surface, Caleb looks like he's got this.Comment
-
-
Going to back Caleb Cole too; he's actually a pretty good fighter. Don't remember Frank very well.Comment
Comment